SEMCO
Get a Quote

Evaporation & ZLD · Free tool

Evaporator energy and cost comparison: single effect, MEE, TVR and MVR

Enter your evaporation duty and your steam and power prices. The calculator shows the steam, power and yearly running cost of each evaporator type side by side, and how much more each option is worth paying for.

Steam kg/hPower kWAnnual cost ₹Break-even priceCO₂

1. Your duty

Start from

kg/h
% w/w
% w/w

Water to evaporate: 5,000 kg/h

2. Your utility costs

₹ per tonne

Coal-fired steam in India is often ₹1,800–3,000 per tonne.

₹ per kWh
hours/year

7,200 h ≈ 300 days at 24 hours.

3. Process details (for MVR)

°C
°C

Salty brines: 3–10 °C

°C

Typical 5–8 °C

years

Lowest running cost

MVR

₹83.44 lakh per year

Saving vs single effect

₹8.02 crore

per year

Evaporation

5,000kg/h

OptionSteam kg/hPower kWEconomyRunning cost / year

Single effect

5,55610.00.90₹8.86 crore

3-effect MEE

1,96110.02.55₹3.16 crore

4-effect MEE

1,47110.03.40₹2.39 crore

5-effect MEE

1,17610.04.25₹1.92 crore

3-effect MEE + TVR

1,18810.04.21₹1.94 crore

MVR

100117.4–₹83.44 lakh

How much extra each option is worth paying

The extra price over a single effect that each option repays from running-cost savings within 3 years. If the extra quoted price is lower than this, it pays back sooner.

  • 3-effect MEE₹17.08 crore
  • 4-effect MEE₹19.41 crore
  • 5-effect MEE₹20.81 crore
  • 3-effect MEE + TVR₹20.75 crore
  • MVR₹24.07 crore

Single effect

Simplest and cheapest to build. Suits small or intermittent duties.

CO₂: about 12,051 t/year

3-effect MEE

Common choice for ZLD and process duties.

CO₂: about 4,286 t/year

4-effect MEE

Good balance of steam saving and cost.

CO₂: about 3,228 t/year

5-effect MEE

Needs enough temperature difference and low boiling point rise.

CO₂: about 2,592 t/year

3-effect MEE + TVR

Needs motive steam at about 8 bar(g) or more.

CO₂: about 2,618 t/year

MVR

Compressor about 21.5 kWh per tonne for a 8.0 °C temperature lift.

CO₂: about 816 t/year

Want these numbers checked?

Send them to a SEMCO process engineer for a free review, sizing and budget price.

Discuss on WhatsApp

How this calculator works

The calculator first works out how much water you need to evaporate. If you give the feed flow and the feed and product concentrations, it uses a solids balance: the solids that enter leave in the concentrate, so the rest is water vapour.

For steam-driven evaporators it divides the evaporation by a typical steam economy: about 0.9 kg of water per kg of steam for a single effect, and 0.85 per effect for a multi-effect evaporator (MEE), which allows for heat losses and feed heating. A thermocompressor (TVR) on a 3-effect plant raises the economy by about 65 percent.

For MVR it calculates the compressor work needed to lift the vapour temperature by the boiling point rise plus the heating temperature difference, using an isentropic compression estimate and an overall efficiency of 72 percent. All options include about 2 kWh per tonne for pumps, vacuum and the cooling tower.

Running cost is steam cost plus power cost over your running hours. The break-even figure is the yearly saving against a single effect multiplied by your chosen payback period.

Formulas used

Water evaporated from a solids balance

E=F(1−xfeedxproduct)

Steam for a steam-driven evaporator

S=Eeconomy, economyMEE≈0.85×n

MVR compressor work (isentropic, ideal gas)

w=1η·kk−1RT1[(P2P1)(k−1)/k−1]

k = 1.33 for steam, R = 461.5 J/kg·K, η = 0.72. P₁ and P₂ are the saturation pressures at the boiling temperature and at the boiling temperature plus the lift.

Yearly running cost

C=(S1000csteam+P cpower)×h

Assumptions and limits

  • Steam economies are typical values for well-designed forward-feed plants. Real plants vary with feed temperature, heat recovery and the number of preheaters.
  • TVR assumes enough motive steam pressure (usually 8 bar(g) or more) and an entrainment ratio of about 1.
  • MVR make-up steam is taken as 2 percent of the evaporation. Compressor power rises quickly if the boiling point rise is high.
  • CO₂ uses 0.30 kg per kg of coal-fired steam and 0.71 kg per kWh of Indian grid power.
  • Capital cost is not estimated, because it depends on materials, scaling, crystallisation and site conditions. Use the break-even figure against real quotes.

Worked example

6,000 kg/h of effluent at 5% TDS, concentrated to 30%, steam at ₹2,200/t, power at ₹8/kWh, 7,200 h/year.

  1. Water evaporated = 6,000 × (1 − 5/30) = 5,000 kg/h.
  2. Single effect: 5,000 ÷ 0.9 ≈ 5,556 kg/h of steam. At ₹2,200 per tonne for 7,200 hours that is about ₹8.8 crore a year.
  3. 4-effect MEE: economy 0.85 × 4 = 3.4, so about 1,470 kg/h of steam, roughly ₹2.3 crore a year plus a small power cost.
  4. MVR at 70 °C with 2 °C boiling point rise and 6 °C heating ΔT: about 21.5 kWh/t for the compressor plus 2 kWh/t auxiliaries, so about 117 kW. Power costs about ₹0.68 crore a year and make-up steam about ₹0.16 crore.
  5. Against a single effect, MVR saves about ₹8 crore a year, so over 3 years it is worth paying up to about ₹24 crore more. That margin is why large continuous duties usually choose MVR or a multi-effect plant.

Frequently asked questions

Which evaporator has the lowest running cost?

Usually MVR, because it replaces most of the steam with electricity at about 15 to 25 kWh per tonne evaporated. Where steam is very cheap, or the boiling point rise is high, a multi-effect evaporator with TVR can be cheaper to run.

How accurate is this calculator?

It is meant for early comparisons and budgets, typically within 10 to 20 percent of a detailed design for the same assumptions. The final figure depends on your liquid, heat recovery and equipment choice.

What steam economy should I expect from a multi-effect evaporator?

About 0.8 to 0.9 kg of water per kg of steam for each effect, so a 4-effect plant typically gives 3.2 to 3.6. A thermocompressor can raise this substantially.

Why does the MVR result change so much with boiling point rise?

The compressor has to raise the vapour temperature by the boiling point rise before any heat can flow, so every extra degree adds compression work. Above about 8 to 10 °C, a hybrid with a steam-driven finisher is often better.

Can I use this for a ZLD plant?

Yes, for the evaporation stage. For the whole ZLD train, including RO, evaporation and the dryer, use the ZLD plant sizing estimator.

Need it designed and built?

SEMCO designs, fabricates and commissions evaporators, ZLD plants, heat exchangers, reactors and vacuum systems in its own factories in Pune and Solapur.

Results are engineering estimates for early sizing and budgeting. Final designs depend on your liquid, site and codes, and are confirmed in SEMCO's proposal. Method reviewed by Jogender Dhayal, Director, SEMCO.