SEMCO
Get a Quote
Back to all articles
Process Engineering

Rising Film Evaporator: Design and When to Choose It Over Falling Film

9 min readSEMCO Process Engineering TeamReviewed by Jogender Dhayal

In short

A rising (climbing) film evaporator boils liquid in long vertical tubes heated from outside; the vapour formed drags a thin film of liquid up the tube wall. It needs no distributor or recirculation pump and handles mild foaming well, but it needs a large temperature difference, often 20–40 °C. A falling film evaporator works at 3–10 °C, so it is the better choice for multiple effects, MVR and heat-sensitive products.

A rising film evaporator, also called a climbing film or long-tube vertical evaporator, is one of the simplest ways to concentrate a thin liquid. Feed enters the bottom of long vertical tubes heated by steam. It boils, and the vapour moving up the tube drags a thin film of liquid up the wall with it. The mixture of vapour and concentrate leaves the top of the tubes and goes to a separator.

The design has no feed distributor and usually no recirculation pump. That makes it cheap and forgiving to build. The catch is that the vapour does the pumping, so the evaporator needs a large temperature difference between steam and product, typically 20–40 °C. A falling film evaporator does the same job at 3–10 °C, which is why falling film has replaced rising film in most multiple-effect and vapour recompression plants.

This guide explains how a rising film evaporator works, where it still makes sense, how to size one, the problems to expect, and how it compares with falling film and other types.

How does a rising film evaporator work?

Each tube passes through three zones from bottom to top:

  1. Sensible heating zone. Liquid enters below its boiling point (because of the hydrostatic head) and is heated. Heat transfer here is by convection and is relatively poor.
  2. Boiling zone. Bubbles form and grow into slugs. As more liquid flashes, the flow becomes churn flow.
  3. Climbing film zone. At high vapour fractions the vapour forms a fast core up the centre of the tube. It shears the liquid into a thin annular film on the wall. This zone has the best heat transfer.

At the top, the vapour and concentrate leave at high velocity, commonly 20–50 m/s at the tube outlet under vacuum, into a vapour head or a tangential-entry separator. The separator removes droplets before the vapour goes to a condenser or the next effect.

Typical construction:

ItemTypical range
Tube length4–7 m (older units up to 10 m)
Tube size25–50 mm OD, 1.2–2 mm wall
Tube materialSS304, SS316L, duplex or titanium for chlorides
Steam sideShell, single pass, with vent and condensate drain at the bottom
Liquid holdupLow, residence time in tubes of seconds to about a minute
OperationUsually once-through; partial recirculation possible

Because the product passes once through the tubes, the concentrate is in contact with the hot wall only briefly. That is good for mildly heat-sensitive products such as herbal extracts, gelatine or some fruit juices, though a falling film unit is gentler again.

When should you choose a rising film evaporator?

A rising film evaporator makes sense when most of the following are true:

  • A large temperature difference is available. For example, steam at 2–3 bar(g) against product boiling at 60–80 °C under vacuum. This is typical of a single-effect unit or the first effect of a small train.
  • The feed is dilute and thin. Viscosity at boiling below roughly 50–100 cP, with little suspended solids.
  • The product foams mildly. The high vapour velocity breaks foam in the tubes, and the separator handles the rest. Rising film was traditionally used for foaming liquids for this reason.
  • Capacity is small to medium and the budget is tight. No distributor, no recirculation pump and simple controls.
  • You want low holdup so that start-up, shut-down and product changeover are quick.

It is a poor choice when:

  • Only a small temperature difference is available, as in effects 2 onwards of a multi-effect evaporator or any MVR evaporator.
  • The liquid scales or crystallises. The sensible heating zone at the bottom and dry patches at the top both foul quickly. A forced circulation evaporator is the normal answer.
  • The product is viscous or must be taken to high concentration. An agitated thin film evaporator handles this better.
  • The feed rate varies widely. Rising film has a narrow stable operating range.

Rising film vs falling film: the key differences

FactorRising filmFalling film
What moves the filmVapour drag (upwards)Gravity (downwards)
Temperature difference neededLarge, 20–40 °C typicalSmall, 3–10 °C
Feed distributorNot neededEssential, must be well designed
RecirculationUsually noneOften needed to keep tubes wetted
Hydrostatic boiling point riseYes, at the tube bottomNegligible
Suitability for MEE / TVR / MVRFirst effect onlyEvery effect; standard for MVR
Heat-sensitive productsGoodBetter (shorter, more uniform contact)
Foaming liquidsGoodFair to good, depends on separator
Viscosity limitLow, about 50–100 cPModerate, a few hundred cP with care
TurndownNarrowWider, if wetting rate is maintained
Fouling riskHigher at tube bottom and top dry patchesLower if tubes stay wetted
Capital costLowerHigher (distributor, recirculation)

The single most important line is the temperature difference. In a four-effect evaporator with steam at 2 bar(g) and the last effect at 50 °C, the total available temperature difference is roughly 133 − 50 = 83 °C. After boiling point rise in each effect, each effect gets perhaps 15–18 °C. A rising film tube would struggle in the later effects. A falling film tube runs comfortably. With MVR, only 5–8 °C is available, which rules rising film out completely.

For more on the falling film side, see our falling film evaporator engineering guide and the comparison of falling film vs forced circulation.

How do you size a rising film evaporator?

The basic sizing equation is the same as for any evaporator:

Q=U A ΔTeff

where Q is the heat duty, U the overall heat transfer coefficient, A the heat transfer area and ΔTeff the effective temperature difference.

Step 1: Mass balance

For feed F at solids fraction xF concentrated to xP:

P=FxFxP,  E=F−P

Step 2: Heat duty

If the feed arrives below boiling point, add the sensible heat:

Q=F cp (Tb−TF)+E λ

where λ is the latent heat at the boiling temperature. Preheating the feed close to its boiling point, for example with condensate, shortens the poor sensible-heating zone in the tubes and improves performance.

Step 3: Effective temperature difference

ΔTeff=Tsteam−(Tsat+BPR+ΔThydro)

ΔThydro is the extra boiling point rise caused by the liquid head at the bottom of the tubes. Under vacuum this matters: a 1 m equivalent head of liquid can raise the local boiling point by several degrees. A common allowance is 2–5 °C on an average basis, more for long tubes at deep vacuum.

Step 4: Choose U

Typical overall coefficients for clean tubes with water-like liquids:

DutyU, W/m²·K
Dilute aqueous solution, steam heated, good ΔT1,500–2,500
Moderate viscosity (10–50 cP)800–1,500
Organic solvents600–1,200

Then apply a fouling allowance based on the actual product. Use pilot or plant data where available.

Step 5: Tube count and length

Area per tube is π do L. Divide the required area by this to get the tube count. Check that each tube receives enough feed to stay wetted at the top, and that the outlet vapour velocity is not so high that pressure drop and entrainment become a problem.

Worked example (hypothetical)

A plant wants to concentrate 2,000 kg/h of a dilute aqueous extract from 5% to 25% solids in a single-effect rising film evaporator.

  • Product: P=2000×0.05/0.25=400 kg/h
  • Evaporation: E=2000−400=1600 kg/h
  • Boiling at about 0.31 bar(a), so Tsat≈70 °C and λ≈2333 kJ/kg. Feed is preheated to near boiling.
  • Duty: Q=1600×2333/3600≈1037 kW
  • Steam at 0.5 bar(g), about 111 °C. Allow 1 °C BPR and 4 °C hydrostatic rise: ΔTeff=111−75=36 °C
  • Take U=1500 W/m²·K

A=1,037,0001500×36≈19.2 m2

Add 10% margin, so about 21 m². With 38.1 mm OD tubes, 6 m long, each tube gives π×0.0381×6≈0.72 m², so about 30 tubes are needed. Steam at 111 °C has a latent heat of about 2,226 kJ/kg, so steam use is roughly 1037×3600/2226≈1,680 kg/h, a steam economy of about 0.95 kg vapour per kg steam. Adding a second effect, or thermal vapour recompression, would cut this substantially.

You can check the heat transfer area with our heat exchanger calculator, saturation temperatures with the steam table, and the separator with the vapour–liquid separator sizing tool.

What goes wrong with rising film evaporators?

ProblemLikely causeFix
Unstable, surging flowΔT too low; feed rate too high for the heat inputRaise steam pressure or vacuum; reduce feed; check non-condensable venting
Low concentration at outletTubes partly flooded; poor vacuum; fouled tubesCheck vacuum system and steam-side venting; clean tubes
Scaling at tube bottomLong sensible heating zone; cold feedPreheat feed close to boiling; control pH or antiscalant
Burnt or scaled tube topsFilm breaks into dry patches; feed rate too low or ΔT too highKeep minimum feed rate; reduce steam pressure; add partial recirculation
Product carryover into condensateHigh outlet velocity; undersized separator; foamingLarger vapour head, tangential entry, mesh or vane demister
Falling capacity over weeksFouling, or air leaks reducing vacuumSchedule CIP; leak test the vacuum side

Most field problems trace back to two things: not enough temperature difference and feed that is too cold. Both are design decisions, so get them right at the start.

Rising–falling film and other variations

  • Rising–falling film. The feed rises through one tube bundle and falls through a second. This lengthens the effective path without a very tall unit and was common in older juice and dairy plants.
  • Partial recirculation. Recycling some concentrate to the inlet keeps the tops wetted at low feed rates. It increases average residence time, so it is a trade-off for heat-sensitive products.
  • Rising film as first effect. In a small two- or three-effect plant, a rising film first effect with high-pressure steam can be followed by falling film effects. This uses the large ΔT where it is available.

Rising film vs other evaporator types at a glance

FeedBest fit
Dilute, thin, mildly foaming, large ΔT availableRising film
Dilute to moderate, heat-sensitive, low ΔT, MEE or MVRFalling film
Scaling, crystallising, salts, ZLD brineForced circulation
Viscous, high-boiling, high final concentrationAgitated thin film evaporator
Final drying to powderAgitated thin film dryer

If you are comparing energy use and cost across options, try the evaporator cost comparison tool.

Conclusion

A rising film evaporator is a simple, low-holdup choice for thin, mildly foaming liquids when steam can supply a large temperature difference. Where only a few degrees are available, as in multiple effects or MVR, or where the product scales or thickens, falling film, forced circulation or thin film evaporators are better. Send your feed analysis, capacity and steam conditions to SEMCO and our process team will suggest the right evaporator type and size.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a rising film and a falling film evaporator?

In a rising film evaporator, feed enters at the bottom and the vapour pushes a liquid film up the tube. In a falling film evaporator, feed is distributed at the top and gravity pulls the film down. Rising film needs a large temperature difference to create enough vapour; falling film works at a small one and needs a good distributor.

What temperature difference does a rising film evaporator need?

Usually 20–40 °C between the heating steam and the boiling liquid. Below about 15 °C there is not enough vapour to lift the film and the tubes run partly flooded, so heat transfer falls and operation becomes unstable.

Can a rising film evaporator be used in a multiple-effect or MVR system?

It can be used as the first effect, where the steam-side temperature difference is large. It is a poor choice for later effects or MVR, where only a few degrees are available. Falling film suits those duties better.

Is a rising film evaporator good for viscous liquids?

No. It works best for low-viscosity liquids, roughly up to 50–100 cP at boiling. For viscous or fouling products, use a forced circulation evaporator or an agitated thin film evaporator.

Topic Tags:Rising Film EvaporatorClimbing Film EvaporatorFalling Film EvaporatorEvaporator DesignHeat Transfer

Related SEMCO Equipment & Solutions

Free tools for this topic

Related Engineering Articles